zhaoli/tac-exp-dev
0
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

ch11: signal-quality gate REFUTED — walk-forward workflow shows gate harmful (exp 61-67, EVIDENCE#053)

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
zhaoli
2026-08-21 02:35:50 +00:00
parent 1603a063ba
commit 6e3c82408c
26 changed files with 4934 additions and 27 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
book/data/diag_script_vs_wf/diagnosis.json
+117
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,117 @@
[
{
"year": "2026",
"script_weekly_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.0921,
"sharpe": 0.5512,
"maxDD": -0.0947
},
"script_weekly_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.088,
"sharpe": 0.5545,
"maxDD": -0.0901
},
"daily_topk_100": {
"ann_ret": -0.0914,
"sharpe": -0.5241,
"maxDD": -0.1446
},
"daily_topk_95": {
"ann_ret": -0.0863,
"sharpe": -0.5214,
"maxDD": -0.1376
}
},
{
"year": "2025",
"script_weekly_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.1774,
"sharpe": 0.9416,
"maxDD": -0.1809
},
"script_weekly_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.1688,
"sharpe": 0.9431,
"maxDD": -0.1725
},
"daily_topk_100": {
"ann_ret": -0.2439,
"sharpe": -0.8798,
"maxDD": -0.2807
},
"daily_topk_95": {
"ann_ret": -0.2316,
"sharpe": -0.8794,
"maxDD": -0.2677
}
},
{
"year": "2024",
"script_weekly_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.0316,
"sharpe": 0.232,
"maxDD": -0.0807
},
"script_weekly_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.0304,
"sharpe": 0.2353,
"maxDD": -0.0768
},
"daily_topk_100": {
"ann_ret": -0.041,
"sharpe": -0.2846,
"maxDD": -0.1248
},
"daily_topk_95": {
"ann_ret": -0.0385,
"sharpe": -0.2815,
"maxDD": -0.1188
}
},
{
"year": "2023",
"script_weekly_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.1025,
"sharpe": 0.7325,
"maxDD": -0.1237
},
"script_weekly_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.0976,
"sharpe": 0.7345,
"maxDD": -0.1178
},
"daily_topk_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.1847,
"sharpe": 1.2305,
"maxDD": -0.1314
},
"daily_topk_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.1753,
"sharpe": 1.2295,
"maxDD": -0.1252
}
},
{
"year": "2021",
"script_weekly_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.1458,
"sharpe": 0.8808,
"maxDD": -0.1115
},
"script_weekly_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.1387,
"sharpe": 0.8824,
"maxDD": -0.1061
},
"daily_topk_100": {
"ann_ret": 0.0009,
"sharpe": 0.0051,
"maxDD": -0.129
},
"daily_topk_95": {
"ann_ret": 0.0016,
"sharpe": 0.0095,
"maxDD": -0.1228
}
}
]
book/data/diag_script_vs_wf/diagnosis_v2.json
+142
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,142 @@
[
{
"year": "2026",
"weekly_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0921,
"sharpe": 0.5512,
"maxDD": -0.0947
},
"weekly_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.088,
"sharpe": 0.5545,
"maxDD": -0.0901
},
"weekly_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0647,
"sharpe": 0.4077,
"maxDD": -0.0945
},
"daily_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": -0.0914,
"sharpe": -0.5241,
"maxDD": -0.1446
},
"daily_100_10bp": {
"ann_ret": -0.1581,
"sharpe": -0.9069,
"maxDD": -0.1765
}
},
{
"year": "2025",
"weekly_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1774,
"sharpe": 0.9416,
"maxDD": -0.1809
},
"weekly_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1688,
"sharpe": 0.9431,
"maxDD": -0.1725
},
"weekly_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.1436,
"sharpe": 0.8026,
"maxDD": -0.1754
},
"daily_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": -0.2439,
"sharpe": -0.8798,
"maxDD": -0.2807
},
"daily_100_10bp": {
"ann_ret": -0.2975,
"sharpe": -1.0722,
"maxDD": -0.314
}
},
{
"year": "2024",
"weekly_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0316,
"sharpe": 0.232,
"maxDD": -0.0807
},
"weekly_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0304,
"sharpe": 0.2353,
"maxDD": -0.0768
},
"weekly_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0051,
"sharpe": 0.0393,
"maxDD": -0.0796
},
"daily_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": -0.041,
"sharpe": -0.2846,
"maxDD": -0.1248
},
"daily_100_10bp": {
"ann_ret": -0.1126,
"sharpe": -0.7819,
"maxDD": -0.1548
}
},
{
"year": "2023",
"weekly_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1025,
"sharpe": 0.7325,
"maxDD": -0.1237
},
"weekly_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0976,
"sharpe": 0.7345,
"maxDD": -0.1178
},
"weekly_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0724,
"sharpe": 0.5449,
"maxDD": -0.1238
},
"daily_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1847,
"sharpe": 1.2305,
"maxDD": -0.1314
},
"daily_100_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0967,
"sharpe": 0.6449,
"maxDD": -0.1481
}
},
{
"year": "2021",
"weekly_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1279,
"sharpe": 0.7781,
"maxDD": -0.1122
},
"weekly_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1219,
"sharpe": 0.7803,
"maxDD": -0.1068
},
"weekly_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0971,
"sharpe": 0.6218,
"maxDD": -0.1079
},
"daily_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": -0.0098,
"sharpe": -0.0564,
"maxDD": -0.1296
},
"daily_100_10bp": {
"ann_ret": -0.089,
"sharpe": -0.509,
"maxDD": -0.1869
}
}
]
book/data/diag_script_vs_wf/diagnosis_v3.json
+142
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,142 @@
[
{
"year": "2026",
"ideal_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0921,
"sharpe": 0.5512,
"maxDD": -0.0947
},
"ideal_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.088,
"sharpe": 0.5545,
"maxDD": -0.0901
},
"ideal_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0647,
"sharpe": 0.4077,
"maxDD": -0.0945
},
"wf_exact_95_nogate": {
"ann_ret": 0.2117,
"sharpe": 1.2681,
"maxDD": -0.1039
},
"wf_exact_95_gate": {
"ann_ret": 0.0146,
"sharpe": 0.1372,
"maxDD": -0.0668
}
},
{
"year": "2025",
"ideal_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1774,
"sharpe": 0.9416,
"maxDD": -0.1809
},
"ideal_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1688,
"sharpe": 0.9431,
"maxDD": -0.1725
},
"ideal_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.1436,
"sharpe": 0.8026,
"maxDD": -0.1754
},
"wf_exact_95_nogate": {
"ann_ret": 0.2273,
"sharpe": 1.1963,
"maxDD": -0.1864
},
"wf_exact_95_gate": {
"ann_ret": 0.0777,
"sharpe": 0.8239,
"maxDD": -0.0773
}
},
{
"year": "2024",
"ideal_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0316,
"sharpe": 0.232,
"maxDD": -0.0807
},
"ideal_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0304,
"sharpe": 0.2353,
"maxDD": -0.0768
},
"ideal_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0051,
"sharpe": 0.0393,
"maxDD": -0.0796
},
"wf_exact_95_nogate": {
"ann_ret": 0.0616,
"sharpe": 0.4145,
"maxDD": -0.0951
},
"wf_exact_95_gate": {
"ann_ret": -0.0261,
"sharpe": -0.2782,
"maxDD": -0.1157
}
},
{
"year": "2023",
"ideal_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1025,
"sharpe": 0.7325,
"maxDD": -0.1237
},
"ideal_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.0976,
"sharpe": 0.7345,
"maxDD": -0.1178
},
"ideal_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0724,
"sharpe": 0.5449,
"maxDD": -0.1238
},
"wf_exact_95_nogate": {
"ann_ret": 0.0327,
"sharpe": 0.2259,
"maxDD": -0.1517
},
"wf_exact_95_gate": {
"ann_ret": 0.0094,
"sharpe": 0.0968,
"maxDD": -0.1036
}
},
{
"year": "2021",
"ideal_100_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1279,
"sharpe": 0.7781,
"maxDD": -0.1122
},
"ideal_95_zc": {
"ann_ret": 0.1219,
"sharpe": 0.7803,
"maxDD": -0.1068
},
"ideal_95_10bp": {
"ann_ret": 0.0971,
"sharpe": 0.6218,
"maxDD": -0.1079
},
"wf_exact_95_nogate": {
"ann_ret": 0.0476,
"sharpe": 0.0429,
"maxDD": -0.3489
},
"wf_exact_95_gate": {
"ann_ret": -0.0227,
"sharpe": -0.0318,
"maxDD": -0.2398
}
}
]